Can You Refuse to Give Your My Number? Six Counterparties

16 recent visitors

This is a translation of the Japanese original. The Japanese version is authoritative; figures follow Japanese tax law.

If you refuse to hand over your My Number (My Number, the 12-digit individual number), will your paperwork be turned away? The answer depends on who is asking. A final tax return or a resident tax return is accepted with the number box left blank. The tax law sets no penalty for leaving it out[National Tax Agency, My Number outline Q2-3-3]. Not giving it to your employer carries no penalty for you, and Hello Work (Hello Work, the public employment security office) accepts employment insurance filings. On the other hand, a new specified account (tokutei koza) or NISA account, and Maru-yu, are closed to you unless you report the number. The premise behind all of this is that entering the number is an obligation laid down in law. This article does not encourage refusing; it sets out, from primary sources, what actually happens with each counterparty.

The short answer: what refusing means, counterparty by counterparty

Who is askingIs filing an obligationWhat happens if you do not
The tax office (final tax return and the like)An obligation laid down in lawAccepted even when blank. There is no penalty provision. The tax office may contact you later
Your employer (dependent deduction declaration form and the like)A legal obligation (a required entry under the Income Tax Act and related rules)No penalty applies to you. The company records "the course of its requests" and files the statutory payment record
Hello Work (employment insurance filings)The sameAccepted with a statement of the refusal attached. Online filings carry "My Number cannot be filed for reasons personal to the employee" in the remarks box
A bank deposit account (attaching the number)Not a legal obligationNo number is attached unless you report it. The account works exactly as before
A securities firm (specified account, NISA, Maru-yu)A notification duty under tax lawYou cannot open or apply anew. Overseas remittances also require a notification form
Your municipality (resident tax return and the like)An obligation laid down in lawAccepted even when blank. There is no penalty provision

Sources: National Tax Agency, Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare, Digital Agency, City of Kagoshima, City of Osaka, Tokyo Metropolitan Bureau of Taxation.

The same shape repeats all the way down the table: it is an obligation, yet leaving it out carries no penalty of its own. The exceptions are the three products at a securities firm and overseas remittances. There, the scheme simply does not work without the number.

The premise: entering the number is an obligation laid down in law

Let us be clear about where we stand. Entering the number on returns and on statutory payment records filed with the tax office is required by the Act on General Rules for National Taxes and the Income Tax Act[National Tax Agency, My Number outline Q2-3-1].

Three phrases that are easy to mix up
  • There is an obligation—the law says "enter it". The tax office, municipalities and employers are all in this group.
  • There is a penalty—leaving it out is punished. No such provision is set under the tax law.
  • The procedure stops—without the number the scheme cannot be used. Only specified accounts, NISA, Maru-yu and overseas remittances are in this group.

These are three different things. "There is no penalty, so I need not write it" does not follow.

The tax office: accepted even when blank, and no one will phone to ask for the number

The National Tax Agency says that, taking into account that understanding of the system takes time to spread, it accepts returns and similar documents even where the number is not entered[National Tax Agency, My Number outline Q2-3-2]. Where an accepted document has the number missing or wrong, the tax law sets no penalty[National Tax Agency, My Number outline Q2-3-3]. The tax office may, however, contact you later.

This is worth remembering as fraud protection too. The National Tax Agency states plainly that "tax officials never ask for your My Number directly over the telephone"[National Tax Agency, My Number outline Q2-3-2]. Anyone phoning to draw the 12 digits out of you is not the tax office.

Your employer: no penalty for you, but the refusal stays on record

Handing your company a dependent deduction declaration form (fuyo kojo-to shinkokusho) with the number on it is a "provision by the person to an entity handling individual-number-related affairs" under Article 19 item 3 of the Numbers Act (Bango-ho)[National Tax Agency, My Number outline Q3-2-1]. The company is the party that enters the number on your withholding tax statement (gensen choshu-hyo) and files it.

What happens when you refuse

  1. The company tells you it is a legal obligation and asks for the number. The Digital Agency gives the same guidance[Digital Agency Q4-2-6].
  2. If it still cannot obtain the number, the company records and keeps "the course of its requests". This is to make clear that it is not simply in breach of its duty[National Tax Agency, withholding income tax Q1-13]. The note adds that the record is not itself a legal obligation, but in practice it is kept.
  3. The company files the statutory payment record with the number box empty. The National Tax Agency asks companies not to enter something casually and file it, but to ask the employee first[National Tax Agency, statutory payment records Q1-2].

Things you need not worry about

Things to accept

  • When it was asked for, and that it could not be obtained, stays on record
  • Online filings carry "My Number cannot be filed for reasons personal to the employee" in the remarks box[Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare]
  • The company's paperwork grows, and the exchange with the person in charge repeats every year

How the qualification confirmation certificate used in place of a health insurance card reaches you is a separate matter from filing the number (who receives the qualification confirmation certificate).

Financial institutions have two layers: a bank account is optional, transactions with a notification duty are not

A bank deposit account is not a legal obligation

The National Tax Agency states that "providing your My Number to a financial institution is not, in law, an obligation"[National Tax Agency, My Number outline Q3-14-2]. The Digital Agency likewise says "no number is attached without the person's own report"[Digital Agency Q9-7]. When you open an account you are asked whether you wish to report it.

Four things you cannot do without the number

What you cannot doBasis
Open a new specified account (tokutei koza)An application form carrying a number different from the one notified cannot be accepted (Act on Special Measures Concerning Taxation, Article 37-11-3)[e-Gov law search]
Open a new NISA accountWhen the application form is filed, your name, address and number must be notified[National Tax Agency]
Use Maru-yu (maru-yu, the tax exemption for small deposits of people with disabilities and others)A tax-exempt savings declaration cannot be accepted if the contents do not match. Without reporting the number, the exemption cannot be applied[National Tax Agency, withholding income tax Q3-4]
Send money abroad, or receive money from abroadA notification form carrying your individual number must be filed (Act on Submission of Statements of Overseas Remittances, Article 3)[e-Gov law search]

Receiving the proceeds of a transfer of shares also carries a notification duty, by the time the payment falls due (Income Tax Act Article 224-3(1))[e-Gov law search]. The six-year grace provision ended on 31 December 2021[National Tax Agency].

"Your general account will be suspended too" cannot be confirmed in primary sources

For customers who have not notified their number, all the National Tax Agency asks financial institutions to do is the clerical work of recording and keeping the course of their requests[National Tax Agency, statutory payment records Q1-10]. Nothing calls for trading to be suspended or accounts frozen. The Digital Agency's wording for general accounts is only that a firm "is understood to be able to" ask for the number[Digital Agency Q4-2-10]. If a firm does stop your trades, that comes from its own terms of business, not from the law.

Municipalities: resident tax returns are accepted blank as well, with no penalty provision

Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications materials say nothing explicit, but the guidance published by municipalities is clear.

MunicipalityPublished treatment
City of KagoshimaThe tax law sets no penalty for failing to enter the number. If you do not know it, file with the box blank and enter it from next time[City of Kagoshima]
City of OsakaWhere you did not bring your card and the number is unknown, the return is accepted without it. If identity cannot be confirmed, that number is not used, but the return is accepted so long as it contains what the tax work requires[City of Osaka]
Tokyo Metropolitan Bureau of TaxationFor depreciable-asset returns, a return is not refused merely because the entry is missing[Tokyo Metropolitan Bureau of Taxation]

The shape is the same as at the tax office. Whether you need to file a resident tax return at all can be worked out in who has to file a resident tax return.

Worth asking before you refuse

What makes people hesitate is usually not the number itself but how the other side will handle it. Asking the following before you refuse settles most of it.

  1. What will it be used for. The number may only be used for work laid down in law or in a local ordinance. Ask for the actual document names: the withholding tax statement, the employment insurance filing. There is no reason to hand it to someone who cannot say why.
  2. How will identity be confirmed. Article 16 of the Numbers Act requires identity confirmation when the number is received. Where identity cannot be confirmed, the number is not used[City of Osaka Q4].
  3. How long will it be kept, and how will it be destroyed. Documents containing the number are destroyed once the retention period ends. It is worth checking with HR what happens after you leave.
  4. Is the request coming by phone or email. Tax officials never ask for the number by phone. Refusing here is the right call.

It pays to keep unease about the system apart from the paperwork in front of you. What stops when you withhold the number is the specified account, NISA and Maru-yu—your own means of saving tax. The documents are still accepted; the tax-free allowances are not.

Summary

  • Providing your My Number is a legal obligation, but tax law sets no penalty for simply leaving it blank.
  • Tax returns and resident tax returns are accepted even with the number field left blank. Tax officials never ask for your number by phone.
  • Not submitting it to your employer carries no penalty for you and you can still receive year-end adjustment deductions, but the record of the employer's request for it is kept on file.
  • Registering it with a bank deposit account is not a legal obligation, and the account remains usable even without it.
  • Opening a new designated account or NISA account, the maru-yu tax exemption for the disabled and elderly, and overseas remittances all require it.

Reference links (sources)

Note: this article is general information. Entering the number is an obligation laid down in law, and nothing here encourages refusing to file it. For an individual decision, ask the tax office, your municipality's counter, or a tax accountant.